Agreement of People website

Sign here if you support the campaign for a real democracy

Our blogs


AWTW FacebookAWTW Twitter

Your Say



Rating agencies tighten the screw

Moody’s has joined other credit rating agencies in downgrading its assessments for France and Spain when it comes to repaying loans. What logic is unfolding here?

The full name of the credit rating agency – Moody’s Investors Service – says it all. The analysis these agencies make and the actions they take are intended to assist those with money to magnify the value of their investments.

Over the last few months, as the crisis has deepened, the significance of Moody’s and the small number of other similar agencies has grown and grown.

In many ways they provide the information needed to allow the operation of the free market, advising investors on the credit-worthiness of borrowers, and helping borrowers to improve their attractiveness to lenders.

Informed investors profit from crisis, as they speculate against future market prices for shares and bonds.

Moody’s cut in Spain’s rating and its warning to France measures the deterioration in conditions in those countries as the recession exposes the weakness of the banks.

The downgraded ratings don’t just measure, however. They have a dual role. They are intended as a direct intimidation to those countries’ governments (and to all the others who are next in firing line).

Unless you take action to ensure that you overcome your difficulties in making these payments, the increased cost of borrowing more will make life impossibly difficult. It’s the classic money lenders’ threat.

The objective conditions that provide evidence for the downgrade are slowing growth, and accelerating recession leading to falling tax revenues which, in turn, make it more and more difficult for governments to make the interest payments due on the money they’ve borrowed.

So the rating cut also translates into a more severe assault on the lives of the people who live in the countries affected. The news about Spain and France came just as trades unions in Greece prepared for a 48 hour strike supported by the burgeoning network of new organisations that have formed to fight the impact of the mounting attacks on living standards.

For governments subservient to the capitalist economy, like the ‘socialist’ Pasok in Greece, cuts are not optional.

For the millions of people whose wages and pensions are melting away, whose jobs are being destroyed, health, education and social support systems being swept from under their feet, fighting the cuts is not optional either.

What resolution can there be to these opposite interests?

Strikes, protests, demonstrations, occupations are all now everyday events. Last Saturday’s occupation of towns and cities throughout the world is an important part of the answer to Moody’s symbolic measure of the power of capital.

But only a part. The regulation of finance demanded by many protestors is not an option for capital either.

This is an epochal moment providing both the necessity and opportunity to replace the rule of capital.

Those who claim to the know, like Mervyn King, governor of the Bank of England, are warning that “time is running out” for the global capitalist economy and that even dealing with Greece and the eurozone crisis will not provide the “solution”.

He is right there. The capitalist system has plunged into an irreversible crisis in which the only answer for the ruling classes is to punish the overwhelming majority through an unprecedented assault on living standards, services, jobs and rights.

In all the temporary and permanent occupations of towns and cities, the question to be raised is not how to better manage capitalist society but how to achieve the democratic ownership and control of the banks, the factories, the mines and the supermarkets.

Gerry Gold
Economics editor
19 October 2011

Bookmark and Share

Your Say

Frank Hayes says:

"It's not in the power of governments to stop companies adjusting to commercial reality". (, Morning Ireland 20/10/2011, 8.25am) So said Richard Bruton, Irish Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, on the morning after Global Corporation Aviva (annual profits measured in billions) announced almost 1,000 job cuts across the country in the next few months.

This, also in the wake of the IMF/ECB/EU Troika visit to Dublin and instruction to the Fine Gael/Labour coalition capitalist government they must cut more public service jobs and pay even more punitive bail outs to the global finance corporations.

Such honesty has been rare up to now, but confirms completely, the truth of Paul's analysis.

Later that day, Taoiseach (PM) Enda Kenny said "Our ambition is to get back to the Bond Markets again". In stark contradiction, the Troika has just said things must be arranged "... so that Ireland does not need to go back to the market for some time".

Confusion? Blather? Bluff? Desperation? All of the above?

The budget is due on 6th December, and clearly, the 'government's' hands are tied behind their backs. They leak word of a further €2Bn cuts, and anger is mounting in communities under the surface everywhere.

The compliant media has twisted the focus of current Presidential Election campaigning to any trivia other than what they sometimes call "the impending crisis". The only anti-establishment candidate has been character-assassinated by a right-wing journalist with the active intervention of Mossad (David Norris is strongly pro-Palestinian).

Expect a sudden and 'unexpected' explosion as the cuts begin to hurt. All the conventional politicos are being outflanked by the daily disintegration of their own system. Regardless of weather, it may soon be rather a hot winter on your neighbouring island.

Comments now closed

We do not store your name or email details, but may inform you if someone responds to your comment.

If you want weekly update messages please indicate and we will store your details in a secure database which is not shared with any other organisation.

Your name

Your E-mail
(we will not publish your E-mail)

Do you want Updates?

Anti-spam validation:compare< Please enter these letters>