Agreement of People website

Sign here if you support the campaign for a real democracy

Our blogs


AWTW FacebookAWTW Twitter

Your Say



Young men as killing machines

We’ve been here before. The killing of at least 16 Afghan civilians – nine of them children – in Kandahar province on Saturday night evokes memories of another atrocity committed by US troops some 44 years ago.

On 16 March 1968, 150 US soldiers in a unit called Charlie Company, led by 24 year-old Lieutenant William Calley, marched into a hamlet called My Lai in Vietnam and massacred 500 unarmed civilians.

Charlie Company’s murder binge was witnessed by a US helicopter crew circling above who tried to stop the killings and rescue survivors. Calley was eventually brought to justice and found guilty of murder. But his life sentence was reduced to three years and he was paroled in 1974. He was pardoned by President Nixon.

Therefore the US authorities’ promise of “a rapid and thorough investigation” into the Kandahar killings must be taken with a huge pinch of salt – let alone the notion that serious punishment will follow.

US officials claim that only one soldier was involved, but several survivors have given conflicting accounts. Residents heard aircraft and helicopters were overhead after midnight on Sunday morning. And 20-year-old Jan Agha, who survived the murder spree by pretending to be dead, said that more than one soldier entered his home.

In February US troops burned copies of the Koran and in January videos of Marines urinating on the bodies of Taliban were circulated. Similar incidents are well-known from Iraq. So is this really the case of a demented rogue? The truth is that holding civilians in contempt and losing all sense of humanity is what happens to the young men trained to be killing machines in countries whose culture, religion and traditions are totally alien to them.

The mother of one of the 404 British soldiers killed in Afghanistan said she only realised this when visiting the country after her son’s death.

The US-British-NATO operations are being conducted by governments who have increasingly lost legitimacy in the eyes of their electorates. Everyone knows they have no solution to the economic and financial crises except to impose intolerable burdens on ordinary people.

It’s not by chance that the six young British soldiers killed in last week’s attack were from unemployment black spots in Yorkshire.

The claims in parliament by David Cameron and Ed Miliband that the British are in Afghanistan to keep the streets of London safe are risible. Al Qaeda is no longer a force in Afghanistan and the Taliban have no intention of coming to Britain any time soon. British troops are no more than cannon fodder for other interests which include protecting the oil pipelines that criss-cross the region.

Journalist and author Simon Jenkins is on the button when he denounces military and political leaders as having lost all contact with reality. Jenkins is hardly a revolutionary, but could be accused of giving solace to the enemy when he writes: “The war the Taliban fighters are waging with vigour and success is to regain the integrity of Afghanistan, no more or less”.

Eventually, seven years after the My Lai massacre, the United States had to pull out of Vietnam, having spent around $770 billion and killed and maimed countless Vietnamese as well as losing nearly 60,000 US troops. The decade-long conflict left a trail of long-term devastation in its wake.

It’s the same in Afghanistan. Service widow Wendy Rayner has noted that after the war in Afghanistan is over, "the poor people who are left will go back to the same crappy lifestyle that they had before our lot went in".

With the US and Britain now turning their attentions towards Iran, the challenge of ending Nato-led wars is an urgent one. That means facing up to the historical fact that war, profits and capitalism are tied in to each other. Ending atrocities like those visited on the people of Afghanistan at the weekend surely means terminating a social system for which war is an extension of its rotten politics.

Corinna Lotz
A World to Win secretary
12 March 2012

Bookmark and Share

Your Say

Left Radical of Afghanistan says:

The mad US militarists and the innocent children of Kandahar

On Sunday early morning March 11, 2012 a group of Special Forces of US, based in Panjwaie district of Kandahar provinces of Afghanistan madly attacked a village and opened fire on people where more than 16 civilians including children and women were killed and 8 others seriously injured. Then, the mission group collected the dead bodies and injured victims and set them on fire. The US Special Force group then left the village and returned to their base.

Based on the witnesses and the injured who survived the atrocity attack, the perpetrator of such dreadful crime was a group of gunmen belongs to US Special Force not a single man. The same claim was confirmed by Dr. Mahmood and Lalai Hamidzai MPs from Kandahar province.

The tragic massacre by US forces in Kandahar is so notorious so as the US government blamed an individual solder for that who suffered from mental problem. The Obama administration tries to reduce the importance of the criminal act and hide the real story from the anti war and anti capitalism people of America and the world. If it was only a single solder behind the bloody attack, it was very easy for the poor but brave villagers of Panjwai that how to give him a lesson as they did with Dr. Brydon a UK army Commander in 1842 Anglo-Afghan first war.

It is really a question that has the US army and Special Force constituted individuals with mental problems? According to the recent months news the US forces in Afghanistan bombarded a wedding party in Kunar province, bombarded a girl’s school in Jalalabad, cut off the fingers of dead bodies in Kandahar, urinated on dead bodies in Helmand, tortured the prisoners until they lose their lives in Bagaram and Kandahar provinces, let the dogs on women and children during home searching in Khost province, committed sex harassment in Eastern and Southern provinces, shot drivers and people on the road to open their way… There are hundreds of such cases that never leak to media.

Left Radical Organization of Afghanistan intensively condemn the brutal massacre of US forces in Kandahar and ask the conscious people of America and world to continue their solidarity with anti occupation resistance in Afghanistan and fight for immediate withdrawal of all invader forces from Afghanistan. The people of Afghanistan and the victims’ families never solicit Obama and Karzai to look at their terrible situation under the feet of aggressive forces. The people of Afghanistan and the victims will never knock the doors of UN and EU for their “humanitarian measures” and judgment because they are the partners of this catastrophic scenario in Afghanistan.

The workers, the oppressed and youth of Afghanistan along with the anti imperialism and capitalism workers and youths must join their hands to resist and defend their rights to live in peace and fully enjoy social, political and economical freedoms.

The imperialist and their made herds of army and police joy to see workers and the oppressed wet in their blood to insure profit for the bosses as well as they become happy to watch gunshot innocent children crying and slithering in their bloods. The mad and mental patients must be treated in hospital not to be deployed in war field. It is not only the individual solders involved in the mentioned massacre but also Obama, Panetta… are responsible for and must be accountable to the history and people of Afghanistan as well as to the murdered innocent little girls.

Left Radical Organization of Afghanistan (LRA)
March 13, 2012 - Afghanistan

Comments now closed

We do not store your name or email details, but may inform you if someone responds to your comment.

If you want weekly update messages please indicate and we will store your details in a secure database which is not shared with any other organisation.

Your name

Your E-mail
(we will not publish your E-mail)

Do you want Updates?

Anti-spam validation:compare< Please enter these letters>