Music for the children of our time

The Edukators

The angry man of sculpture

Attack on artistic freedom in Russia

Pushing at the edges

The secret life of objects

Porcelain that challenged the world

Bill Brandt

Heaven on Earth: Art from Islamic Lands


The inspiration of Italian cinema


Pissarro in London

Of Villains and Villeins

Piazzas on the eve of destruction

Modernism resurgent

Wilkie - Painter of everyday life

Techno-gothic fusion


Gagarin Way


Vietnam behind the lines

Romney - mirroring the gentry

Caspar David Friedrich - the essential Romantic

The awesome effects of the sublime

Earth & fire

Paul Klee: The nature of creation

John Pilger's Great Eyewitness Photographers

Sarah Medway: In the Realm of the Senses

A glimpse of the Hermitage

Vermeer at the National Gallery

Paul Signac: Travels in France

The other story of British abstract art

Breaking the silence

Century City

Digitising the Hermitage

Ghosts of christmas past

The disasters of war

Picturing the people's game

Picasso as political icon

An art world Schindler

British modernism reclaimed

Brush Power

The modern bronze age

The first museum of modern art

Six women who shook the world

Frances Aviva Blane

Caro's challenge

Ellsworth Kelly at the Tate

Magnum resists the lure of the dollar

Rebel behind the American movement

E-mail to hear about site changes, placing 'update' in body of message



A quest for freedom in unified Germany

At last a film that grasps the nettle. There are plenty of challenging political thoughts and arguments in Hans Weingartner’s second feature film, and yet it is nuanced, humorous and has a superb lightness of touch. The Edukators depicts a rite of passage, love story and history lesson all rolled into one. Looking deeper into the director and actors’ own lives and experiences, it can be viewed as symbolic of post-1989 Germany.

After the fall of the Wall, youths from east and west Germany moved into empty buildings in East Berlin as rents skyrocketed. A Squatters’ Council was formed representing more than 120 squatted buildings. During the 1990s, squatters and police were at loggerheads as the youth were cleared out of one building after the other.

Weingartner, who is 33, says The Edukators is about the last ten years of his life. “There are lots of themes in the film, but the theme of revolution, of rebellion is the key one. For my generation, the problem is that we don’t know how to translate our desire for revolution into action; we don’t know how to fight against the system.”

Back in the 1990s, when he was a physics student, he lived in a Berlin squat. “We felt the whole system was wrong. It was bad for the exploited and bad for the exploiters too. It was not only unfair, it was alienating for everyone. All my friends felt the same way, but none of us ever found a political group we could stick with. We didn’t want to be regimented. Like Jule [the film’s heroine], we wanted to be free.”

His squat experience ended with a massive police raid: “They tossed my belongings out of the window. They treated us like dangerous criminals. They destroyed the whole building. When I recovered I promised myself I would incorporate politics into a movie. I have always been interested in socially conscious cinema. I admire Michael Moore, Mike Leigh and Costa Gavras. The Edukators is a film about the scope for political change, but it cannot give answers because there are no clear answers to give.”

The film was shot 100% digitally with no artificial light. “The decision to shoot exclusively with hand-held cameras was important. We were able to explore the space and give actors licence to go wherever they wanted. We ended up with something very mobile, with cast and camera dancing around each other.

“Everything is down to the actors,” Weingartner says. “The camera must follow them, so that it looks like they are determining the shape of each shot. They must look and feel free to move as they please. The position of the camera can never determine what they do. This notion fits in with the film’s impulse towards freedom, spontaneity and lightness.”

Daniel Brühl who starred in Weingartner’s first feature film The White Sound, and has gone on to make Ladies in Lavender with Judi Dench and Maggie Smith, is the quiet but determined centre of the storm. Our view of Brühl’s character, Jan, is coloured by his role in the 2003 hit , Goodbye, Lenin! where he played a sympathetic son who wanted to make time stand still to keep his mother happy.

Julia Jentsch, who plays the girl loved by two young men, trained at Berlin’s Ernst Busch Academy, the toughest and most prestigious theatre school in Germany, named after the singer and actor who worked with Eisler and Brecht. Croatian-born Stipe Erceg as Peter, the second in the trio of rebels, is totally convincing.

Like Goodbye, Lenin!, The Edukators expresses an intense desire for a different kind of world. But instead of recreating the past, it looks at the injustices of the present. Jan and Peter are political activists who seek to subvert the status quo. They break into the homes of the rich to “rearrange” their possessions, creating a chaotic kind of art form.

The story is a denunciation of the inhumanity of corporate control and in Weingartner’s own words “an economic system in which human beings mean nothing and money is everything”. Jule, Peter’s girlfriend, has her own problems, and knows nothing about her boyfriend’s acts of “edukating”. She is weighed down by a huge insurance claim debt, keeping down her job as a waitress and paying the rent.

Successful businessman, Hardenberg (Burghart Klaussner), whose villa is invaded by the Edukators, is himself an ex-1960s rebel. With shades of Joschka Fischer and other Sixties rebels who are now pillars of the system, he rationalises his political degeneration. He thaws out when forced to live cheek by jowl with the rebels, but is manipulative and perfidious to the core.

As the story develops, the three young people are drawn deeper and deeper into defiance of the law. At the same time, their own friendship spins dangerously near destruction. The film deliberately flouts the gloomy view of relationships which Weingartner says dominates most German movies.

In many ways The Edukators does not go beyond the realm of protest – and yet this makes it true to its subjects and its time. But the rebels have a vision and a loyalty to their ideals that show that another world is indeed possible. The film is an inspiring contribution to the current flowering of a new German language cinema.

The Edukators – Die Fetten Jahre sind Vorbei (The Fat Years are Over) opens in the UK in April.

This article first appeared in Socialist Future Review Spring 2005


































For a review of

Sophie Scholl, the final days

+ more film, book and art reviews goto the
A World to Win site